Naughty Charles

During the holidays it can be fun to have a cocktail that is undeniably interesting. For such a need we present the Naughty Charles. This cocktail starts with a familiar base, with Bourbon and Cherry Heering (our own Wallace and Davis!). Leaning into the sweet side, creme de cacao is then added. You’ve got a pretty straight forward desert Old fashioned here, right?! But that’s when the dry vermouth shows up and throws it’s weight around. Top it off with orange bitters (popular in our house martini).

This drink offers up different flavors from the nose to the finish and every step along the way. If you decide to check it out, make sure to stick to the recipe and consider the OXO Jigger which offers up the rare 1/3oz line, used twice in this drink.

Happy Holidays! Cheers!!

1 ½ oz Bourbon

1/3 oz Cherry Heering

1/3 oz White Crème de Cacao

½ oz Dry Vermouth

2 dashes Orange bitters

Add all ingredients to a mixing glass

Add ice and stir for 30 seconds

Strain into a chilled Nick & Nora

Garnish with a lemon twist

Source: Difford’s Guide

Wallace & Davis O.F. (A Runaway Anchor Original)

Originally introduced Dec 23, 2023, this Runaway Original is back for a second holiday season. Kicking off our Menu for the year, enjoy our tasty riff on the old fashioned again!!

The Old Fashioned is a classic. An easy cocktail to make and enjoy at home, or to order from any bar in the world. We thought it would be fun to do a riff on the Old Fashioned for the holidays. This mixture evokes the taste of chocolate covered cherries, but the balance is crucial with this cocktail.

First thing: stick with Bourbon. We tried it with Rye and the spice will quickly overwhelm the delicate balance here (Scotch would also overpower it). Also, abide by the 0.5oz of cherry heering. If you put a full shot in this drink the only thing you’ll taste is cherry. Finally, THREE dashes of the bitters. The last thing you taste should be the chocolate. We hope you enjoy this Runaway Anchor Original Cocktail for the holidays this year (or anytime you’re in the mood for something a little sweet)!

If you’re wondering about the name. This classic cocktail needed a classic holiday movie to go along with it, so we went with White Christmas, naming the cocktail after the characters played by Bing Crosby and Danny Kaye.

Happy Holidays!

2 oz Bourbon

½ oz Cherry Heering Liqueur

3 dashes of Chocolate Bitters

In a Mixing Glass, add all three ingredients

Add ice and stir for 30 seconds

Strain over a single ice cube if possible

Garnish with 2-3 Maraschino Cherries

Source: BC (Co-Founder of the Runaway Anchor Cocktail Bar)

Home on the Range

Sometimes it is just nice to leave all the bartools in the drawer and just mix up a quick cocktail in the glass itself. If you are an Old Fashioned purest, that’s even how you build that classic drink (muddle sugar cube and bitters, top with bourbon and add ice). I prefer the mixing glass most of the time though…

The Home on the Range is a fun twist on the Manhattan, adding the orange liqueur, Cointreau to the mix. If Cointreau isn’t already a staple of your home bar, it needs to be, if nothing else to mix up the Cable Car or make your Margaritas a bit more interesting (technically it is a triple sec, which refers to how it’s made versus what it “is”…)

This cocktail wraps up our list for Fall 2024. It’s been a fun exploration of bourbon this season, so be sure to go back and try all the others, even if that means pulling our a mixing glass or a cocktail shaker in the process. Cheers!

2 oz Bourbon

¼ oz Cointreau

¼ oz Sweet Vermouth

3 dashes Angostura Bitters

Garnish: orange and lemon twist (for the ambitious)

Add all ingredients to a chilled lowball (in the order listed)

Give it a swirl to combine

Drop in a single large cube (carefully!!) And swirl again.

Garnish with orange and lemon twist

Source: Regarding Cocktails by Sasha Petraske

The Left Hand (Runaway Style)

This cocktail was a bit of a journey. At that is all due to the presence of Campari. We introduced our first campari cocktail on the summer menu 2024 with the Jungle Bird. And even that edged towards a bitter level that, for newbies, was almost too bitter. But we are determined to figure out this crazy bottle, so here it is again on our Fall 2024 menu!

The original recipe calls for equal parts Sweet Vermouth and Campari, but we throttled that down a quarter ounce on the Campari to hold off a bit of the bite. And we even stirred a bit in the lowball after straining to take even more bite off the drink. What you end up with is a pretty interesting melding of sweet and bitter and a finishing note of chocolate. Definitely a good cocktail as the season gets cooler these days.

This one can be served up (no ice) or on the rocks (ice). Again, if you are new to Campari (or sweet vermouth) you might want to stick with the dilution you get from ice cubes. Baby steps to the straight up no chaser.

Cheers!

1 ½ oz Bourbon

¾ oz Sweet Vermouth

½ oz Campari

3 dashes Chocolate Bitters

Garnish: Orange Twist wrapped around 3 brandied cherries on a pick (if you are ambitious!)

Add all ingredients to a Mixing Glass

Add ice and shake for 30 seconds

Strain over cubed ice into a lowball glass

Stir to melt a little ice (and cut that campari a bit further)

Source: Regarding Cocktails by Sashe Petraske

Figetaboutit!! (A PDT cocktail bar original)

Our first experience with “jam based cocktails” was the Cosmonaut, which is an amazing riff on the, oh so boring, cosmopolitan. Gin, Lemon and scoop of Raspberry jam. Check that one out! It’ll show up on this site eventually.

For the fall menu, we are introducing a second “jam cocktail” to the mix. This one has lots of interesting flavors that need the right balance to be great. We tried messing with the balance and quickly it was too sweet (upping the amaretto) or too sour (upping the lemon) or boring (lowering either of those). The only modification you might consider is two scoops of the fig jam. That adds a little extra something to the cocktail without throwing it out of balance.

Cheers!

2 oz Bourbon

¼ oz Amaretto

¾ oz Fresh Lemon Juice

1 barspoon Fig Jam

2 dashes Angostura Bitters

Garnish: Orange Twist wrapped around 3 brandied cherries on a pick (if you are ambitious!)

Add all ingredients to a Cocktail Shaker

Add ice and shake for 10-15 seconds

Double strain into a chilled coupe (neat)

Garnish with orange/cherry

Source: The PDT Cocktail Book

The Boo Radley

This entry for the Fall 2024 Menu is very easy and very interesting. Based in bourbon, this cocktail is all about the balance of sweet and bitter. Cynar brings the bitter and Cherry Heering brings the sweet. As always with Cherry Heering, tread lightly. If you had too much, it will be far too sweet and ruin your cocktail. Start low and add if the bitterness is still too much for you.

Cheers!

2 oz Bourbon

¾ oz Cynar

½ oz Cherry Heering Liqueur

Garnish: Lemon and Orange Peel (optional)

Add all ingredients to a Mixing Glass

Add ice and stir for 30 seconds

Strain into a chilled Nick and Nora Glass

Source: The Essential Cocktail Book

Midnight Stinger

This cocktail, coming from the great cocktail book by Steve the Bartender, has been a real hit as we wrap up the summer and get into fall. During our taste testing session this one was my personal favorite of the bunch (and that’s saying something, as will soon be seen when the Fall Menu 2024 launches Sept 1st).

This cocktail has the base of a whiskey sour, but it adds Fernet Branca and changes the whole game. This is an apertive that you will find sitting alongside things like Vermouth, Campari, and Amaro. Fernet can be sipped straight or mixed. We hope this cocktail serves as an introduction to a new bottle that might be less familiar.

Cheers!

1 oz Bourbon

1 oz Fernet Branca

¾ oz Fresh Lemon Juice

¾ oz Simple Syrup

Garnish: Mint

Add all ingredients to a cocktail shaker

Add ice and shake for 10-15 seconds

Double strain into a lowball filled with cubed or pebble ice (if you have it)

Source: Steve the Bartender Midnight Stinger Recipe

Red Raider

This cocktail comes from a share within our Runaway Anchor Patreon Speakeasy group. After making it a couple of times, I would classify this cocktail as “alcoholic tropical punch”. The bourbon is buried in this drink. The citrus is front and center with the lemon (or lime) balancing nicely with the orange in the Curacao and the rich grenadine syrup. If you aren’t making your own grenadine at home, consider buying the one we used from Portland Syrups and created by Anders Erickson. It is awesome!

Enjoy the last month of summer with this smooth sipper! But be careful, as each drink is still packing 2 oz of booze, and if you use a high proof bourbon, this drink could sneak up on you! Drink responsibly.

Cheers!

1½ oz Bourbon

½ oz Dry Curacao

¾ oz Fresh Lemon Juice (or Lime Juice)

½ oz Anders Erickson Grenadine

Add all ingredients to a shake

Add ice and shake for 10-15 seconds

Double strain into a lowball over a single large ice cube

Source: @top_shelf_tre https://www.instagram.com/reel/C9QeRVWPh58/

Whiskey Sour

This is another “anybody can make this cocktail” option. This was the first “complex” cocktail I made that also turned into a showpiece. I say “complex” because it requires quality ingredients and careful attention to the steps. There are two keys to this cocktail. First, always use fresh lemon. I know juicing isn’t convenient, but canned lemon juice will make a bad cocktail. Second, be very careful during the “dry shake” portion of shaking. The key to a shaker (any style) is the cold will hold the shaker together. Without the cold, the shaker will try and expand while shaking, and I have a few experiences with blowing the seal and splattering my kitchen with cocktail ingredients. So pay attention when you dry shake!

Cheers!

1½ oz Bourbon

¾ oz Lemon Juice (fresh)

½ oz Simple Syrup (rich demerara if you have it)

½ oz Egg White (one egg, usually)

3 drops Angostura Bitters (garnish)

Dry shake all ingredient (minus bitters) for 20 seconds

Add ice to shaker and shake 20 seconds

Double Strain into low ball glass with fresh ice cubes

After the foam settles, Drip 3 drops of bitters on top of the cocktail

Source: Anders Erickson Whiskey Sour Recipe

Why Not? – Death and Co. Original

This cocktail is an original, created at Death and Company by Devon Tarby in 2017. This is a twist on the classic sidecar, but adds in maple syrup to the mix. Perfect for the Winter Menu in 2024!

This cocktail features an herbal garnish of a sage leaf. We recommend not skipping the garnish on this one. Just like a Mai Tai just isn’t a Mai Tai without the bouquet of mint at the top of the glass, the “Why Not” mixes taste and smell perfectly here. And the bourbon called for in the recipe is not super expensive; so that’s great! Cheers!

1¾ oz Evan Williams Black Label Bourbon

½ oz Cointreau

¾ oz Fresh Lemon Juice

½ oz Dark Robust Maple Syrup

Garnish: Sage Leaf and Lemon Wheel

Shake all ingredients with ice

Double strain into a double old fashioned glass with ice cubes

Garnish with Sage and Lemon Wheel

Source: Cocktail Codex, a Death and Company book